The Critical Points: First to go were airline cancellation fees, next should be hotel resort fees

In the airline world, fees have become big business. There are checked bag fees, carry-on bag fees, seat assignment fees, fees to print boarding passes, fees to talk to a person and even fees that provide no tangible benefit or service to customers. Think of close-in booking fees, for example, when you may be required to pay $75 or extra miles if you're within 21 days of departure.

There are also change fees, cancellation fees and the complete forfeiture of certain basic economy tickets that don't allow changes or refunds.

But this week, we saw the airline industry take a big step in the right direction when United announced it was getting rid of change fees.

For more TPG news delivered each morning to your inbox, sign up for our daily newsletter.

These fees have always been a way for airlines to increase ancillary revenue. In addition to paying any difference in between your existing and new ticket, a change fee seemed particularly punitive.

But COVID-19 has turned the world upside down and diminished business for airlines and hotels to the point that customers need confidence they'll be able to change plans without being punished, or they simply won't book a trip at all.

United is the first major airline to make this pro-consumer move of permanently removing change fees — though who knows what the carrier's policies will look like in five years. Also, Southwest has never had change fees, and would only charge travelers the fare difference.

So, if an airline can get rid of change fees, which serve no practical purpose and doesn't provide any good or service, a hotel can get rid fo resort fees. Right?

Related: How to avoid resort fees

Daily Newsletter

Reward your inbox with the TPG Daily newsletter

Join over 700,000 readers for breaking news, in-depth guides and exclusive deals from TPG’s experts

Email address

Sign up

By signing up, you will receive newsletters and promotional content and agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Imagine you go to the grocery store to buy a single $2.99 box of cereal. At the register, however, you notice $1 was added to your total. It's listed as a "shopping cart fee" — so you politely tell the manager you didn't use the shopping cart. The manager says the fee helps offset the cost of providing shopping carts for all customers and, sorry, that's the policy whether you use a cart or not.

That's essentially the same as a hotel resort fee: A mandatory charge, often poorly disclosed or not advertised, regardless of whether or not you use the amenities. In reality, it's a way for hotels to increase cash flow while keeping published rates low. It's taxed identically to the advertised room rate.

Resort fees, urban fees, season fees, membership fees, urban retreat fees and whatever else the industry will think to call them next need to go. Now. Continuing to charge resort fees at properties with diminished offerings because of COVID-19 is a new low in the resort fee saga.

Many beachfront and Las Vegas properties, for example, are still charging full resort fees, even though amenities such as the pool, kids club and fitness center have reduced hours or have closed altogether.

Because occupancy remains historically low, now is the perfect time for hotels to give travelers transparent rates, without any hidden fees.

Imagine the publicity boost a national hotel chain would receive if it eliminated resort fees in the name of fair and straightforward pricing. They can — and arguably should — raise average daily room rates to compensate for the lost resort fee, especially as demand increases. Ultimately, travelers should be able to clearly see the all-in rate for a hotel stay and determine if the product (and its amenities) are worth the price.

Related: The 10 most outrageous resort fees

Surely, if Las Vegas stopped advertising $30 room rates with a hidden $44 per night resort fee, and instead advertised a $60 per night all-in rate, there would be wins in terms of both booking and publicity.

Hotels will need to be creative to lure back travelers, and eliminating resort fees is a logical, pro-consumer move to show customers you want and value their business. One look at the positive press United received when it did away with change fees should tell you exactly how hungry the public is for the travel industry to adopt more consumer-friendly policies.

Hotels can build trust with guests and sell rooms for a fair rate without tacking on frustrating mandatory fees. In light of the pandemic, things that seemed improbable -- or even impossible -- six months ago are happening. If an airline like United can shed long-held fees in favor of flexibility and transparency, who's to say a major hotel chain can't do the same?