J.D. Power: Flyers are less satisfied with airlines; JetBlue, Southwest earn top scores

Passenger satisfaction with air travel is waning amid soaring airfares and lingering pandemic service changes.

That’s according to the J.D. Power 2022 North America Airline Satisfaction Study, which found stress and aggravation are returning along with passengers amid a broader rebound in air travel. The decline in 2022's satisfaction rating follows two consecutive years of record-high scores in the J.D. Power report.

“Customer satisfaction with North American airlines climbed to unprecedented highs for all of the wrong reasons during the past two years,” Michael Taylor, travel intelligence lead at J.D. Power, said in a Wednesday statement highlighting the study’s findings. “Fewer passengers meant more space on airplanes, less waiting in line and more attention from flight attendants. But that business model was simply not sustainable.”

Want more airline-specific news? Sign up for TPG's free new biweekly Aviation newsletter

Indeed, passenger numbers plummeted during the pandemic, dropping to historic lows in 2020. But a slow rebound began to take hold in 2021, and it's hit full stride in 2022. Now, travelers face the prospect of full flights and scarce hotel options during what’s shaping up to be a “sold-out summer.”

For J.D. Power's 2022 study, travelers said they were unhappy with airfares that have risen astronomically as passengers have returned faster than airlines have been able to ramp up operations following cutbacks made during the pandemic. And passengers in first and business class seem particularly unhappy with reduced food and beverage service. “Premium passengers want their free drinks,” J.D. Power noted.

“Now, with volumes surging and some remnants of pandemic-era constraints still in place, passenger satisfaction is in decline,” Taylor added. Still, he said “that’s not really bad news” for airlines if they can “find ways to manage these growing volumes while making some small adjustments to help passengers feel more valued.”

Sold-out summer: 31 travel tips to keep your trip on track and on budget

Overall, the industry’s satisfaction score came in at an average of 798 on a 1,000-point scale, a 21-point drop from J.D. Power's record-high score of 819 in 2021.

J.D. Power also shook up the airline ratings that had become a staple of its satisfaction studies over the years. In previous years, J.D. Power rated airlines either in one overall list or by breakdowns that tended to compare full-service and budget carriers in their own categories.

But J.D. Power’s 2022 study instead ranks airlines by three service types: first/business class, premium economy and economy/basic economy. The study is based on responses from 7,004 passengers who flew on a major North American airline within the U.S. and Canada during a 12-month window through March 2022.

Wallet-buster: Why are airfare and hotel rooms so expensive right now?

JetBlue took the top spot in both the first/business and premium economy ratings. That comes despite the fact that JetBlue’s “Mint” business-class seat is available only on select U.S. routes and that it does not offer a formal “premium economy” seat. But J.D. Power lumped JetBlue’s “Even More Space” seats that feature up 7 extra inches of legroom into its premium economy category. JetBlue's strong showing comes during an otherwise eventful year for JetBlue. The carrier made an offer, since spurned, to acquire budget rival Spirit Airlines and has found itself struggling through a springtime bout of delays and cancellations.

Elsewhere in the 2022 J.D. Power study, Southwest finished No. 1 in the “economy/basic economy” category, outpacing No. 2 JetBlue and No. 3 Delta.

Last year, J.D. Power rated the airlines in a single category – with Delta finishing first ahead of Southwest and Alaska.

Shortage alert: Renting a car this summer? Things are getting better, but it could still be dicey

Scroll down for the full 2022 rankings.

First/business class ratings

1. JetBlue (878 on a 1,000-point scale)

2. Alaska Airlines (876 points)

3. Delta Air Lines (862 points)

Average for first/business (837 points)

4. Air Canada (832 points)

5. United Airlines (822 points)

6. American Airlines (814 points)

Summer surge: Memorial Day weekend start of busy summer travel season just 3 weeks away

Premium economy ratings

1. JetBlue (851 points on a 1,000-point scale)

2. Delta Air Lines (837 points)

3. Alaska Airlines (825 points)

Average for premium economy (822 points)

4. American Airlines (818 points)

5. United Airlines (801 points)

6. Air Canada (800 points)

Inflight service is back: Here’s what food and drinks you can expect on your next flight

Economy/basic economy ratings

1. Southwest Airlines (849 points on a 1,000-point scale)

2. JetBlue (828 points)

3. Delta Air Lines (813 points)

4. Allegiant Air (803 points)

5. Alaska Airlines (794 points)

Average for economy (792 points)

6. Air Canada (777 points)

7. United Airlines (774 points)

8. Spirit Airlines (772 points)

9. American Airlines (770 points)

10. Frontier Airlines (755 points)

11. WestJet (751 points)