Skip to content

Why renting a car may now be the hardest part of your journey

Nov. 05, 2020
6 min read
Rental Cars in a lot
This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.

In the hierarchy of necessary tasks to plan and book a trip, securing the rental car isn't usually the top action item. But this year, like with so many other things, the tables have turned -- dramatically. In fact, myriad factors have led to a world in which securing a rental car may, in fact, be the toughest (or most expensive) part of your journey.

Here's what is going on and how to increase the odds you get the rental car you want.

For more TPG travel news and tips delivered each morning to your inbox, sign up for our free daily newsletter.

Rental cars may be completely sold out

TPG's Richard Kerr was recently in Austin, and after a few days working and playing at a resort just outside of Austin, he was ready to rent a car and head to the Houston area to see some family. The problem, by the time he went to rent a car, there wasn't a single car for rent that weekend in all of the greater Austin area.

This phenomenon is not unique to Austin or limited to any one particular weekend. TPG's Clint Henderson rented cars several times during the summer across many states and found that many airport locations were sold out if he waited until the last moment. In particular, Milwaukee was completely out of cars when he wanted to travel.

Solution: While it's not a revolutionary suggestion, a good plan is to book your car rental out as far in advance as you can. If that fails, try off-airport lots, call locations directly and lean into your top-tier car rental elite status if you have any to speak of. But mostly, just don't assume there will be a car available until you book one.

Related: Best credit cards to use for rental cars

(Photo by Francis Joseph Dean/DeanPictures via Getty Images)

It may cost you -- a lot

While there are exceptions, your next car rental may cost more than you wish. When TPG's Henderson was able to book cars over the summer, he found that the rates were very expensive compared to the prices he was paying for flights and hotels.

Looking at an upcoming weekend in Denver at the start of the ski season for some mountains, SUVs are renting from multiple car rental companies for $200+ per day.

Sign up for our daily newsletter

Car rental rates in the NYC area are notoriously expensive and right now is no exception. A standard car weekend rental from JFK starts at $75 per day next week. Over the summer, prices were sometimes even higher. In fact, that's what led to TPG's Scott Mayerowitz booking a car for a month at a time, and eventually deciding that purchasing was a better overall deal.

Solution: TPG has an entire guide on how to never pay full price for a car rental, which is good because you may need every trick in the book right now. Be sure and check for discounts on your credit cards, too, such as this new Amex Offer.

Screenshot courtesy of Amex

Limited lot selection

Remember the days your Five Star row, President's Circle Status or Emerald Aisle choices were ... well, choices?

In many cases right now, you're lucky there's a car at all, and don't count on having any actual choices or upgrades. In fact, the type of car you reserved may not even be available.

Hertz President's Circle at Washington-Dulles airport in 2019. (Photo by Zach Griff/The Points Guy)

On a recent October trip to Orlando, my Hertz rental was the very last one available for pick-up on the Five Star row. A few months earlier, in Panama City, I overheard renters with reservations being told that their large SUVs that had been reserved were unavailable. In some cases, that meant their family could no longer fit in one vehicle.

Solution: Don't hope or count on any type of upgrade. Worse still, realize you may not even get what you paid for. While this may or may not be realistic in your area, I've personally turned to Silvercar when I want to increase the odds I get the car type I need since they have significantly fewer car types than the big chains. On the flip side, even Silvercar has been pulling out some of its previous airport locations so there's no sure-fire solution.

(Photo by Zach Honig/The Points Guy)

Beware the pick-up line

In both of my previously mentioned recent car rental experiences, there was another constant beyond a shortage of cars -- extremely long pick-up lines at some counters. While I didn't have a terribly long wait to pick up my rental cars thanks to having a free Hertz Gold account set up in advance, I saw others in lines that were undoubtedly at least an hour long and sometimes with very mixed mask usage.

The pick-up lines I saw for Payless, Budget, Alamo and the like were not a place I'd like to be if I could avoid it.

Solution: Join your car rental agency's program and complete all paperwork and verifications in advance. I would give a strong preference to programs that allow for touchless rental car pick-up experiences, if possible.

Hertz rental counter at HNL in 2019. (Photo by Summer Hull/The Points Guy)

Bottom line

Rental cars are rarely an exciting part of the travel process, but in 2020, they are a very important part to travel autonomously with your own space. And with travel patterns being shifted a fair bit from the norm for the foreseeable future, you may be shocked at how scarce or expensive car rentals may be on your next trip, especially if you don't plan for those potential realities well in advance.

Featuerd image by by alexfan32/Shutterstock

Featured image by ALEXFAN32/SHUTTERSTOCK