This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.
A new year is a great time to reconsider your airline loyalty. However, deciding which program makes the most sense for you can be a difficult decision given the variations between the programs when it comes to complimentary upgrades, bonus points or miles and other valuable perks.
Today, I’m continuing my revision of last year’s series that considers just how valuable each program’s elite status is mathematically. As in previous iterations, I’ll evaluate the major perks provided at each tier and try to peg a specific value to each. After starting with the American Airlines AAdvantage program, I’ll now move onto Delta and its SkyMiles program.
As I noted in my first post, this series is not meant to replace or detract from the airline elite status analysis I completed in fall 2017. That analysis looked not only at the value of the various perks offered to elite members but also the importance of those perks to travelers. In addition, it didn’t go into details for the individual airlines, instead offering a comparison across the major airlines here in the US. Today’s analysis (and the entries that follow) will do just that.
Before we get to the details of the elite status tiers of the SkyMiles program, a couple of disclaimers. First, it’s important to note that these mathematical analyses represent just one way of calculating the value you’d get out of a given elite status level. Everyone has his or her own way of valuing the various benefits of loyalty programs; some may always pay for first and business class and thus have no need for complimentary upgrades, while others may travel exclusively in the US and don’t care about free lounge access on international itineraries. As a result, feel free to adjust the numbers I use to make it more relevant to your own personal valuation.
Second, these numbers are all based on the benefits you’d enjoy after achieving the given status level and continuing to qualify each year thereafter. If you’re starting from scratch, these values are a bit skewed, since the first 25,000 miles you fly will provide no benefits. I’ve provided some analysis for those of you in that position toward the end of the post, including an Excel spreadsheet to help with your estimates.
This brings me to the third and final critical part of this analysis: the underlying assumptions I’m making. To really hit a value for benefits, I have to assume a certain amount of flying and a corresponding amount of spending. For the sake of the airline portion of the series, I’m making the following assumptions:
- You earn 20% more Medallion Qualification Miles (MQMs) than the minimum required for the given status level.
- You spend an average of 15 cents per MQM.
As always, be sure to adjust these numbers based on your given travel patterns. Those who travel exclusively in the US may spend less than $0.15 per mile, while those who travel in paid first or business class internationally likely spend significantly more. You also may qualify on segments rather than miles, and you may have heavier travel in certain parts of the year.
Two final bits of information: For the sake of this analysis, I’m valuing any bonus miles earned based on TPG’s most recent valuations, which peg SkyMiles at 1.2 cents apiece. In addition, I’m rounding all of the individual benefit valuations to the nearest $5 to make the math a bit simpler.
So … all that being said, where do the four elite levels of the SkyMiles program land? Here’s my analysis:
Delta Silver Medallion ($900)
The lowest tier in Delta’s program is Silver Medallion status, which normally requires 25,000 MQMs or 30 Medallion-qualifying segments plus $3,000 Medallion-Qualfying Dollars (MQDs). For this analysis, I’ll base my numbers on earning 30,000 MQMs at a cost of 15 cents per mile (so a total spend of $4,500).
- Unlimited complimentary first-class upgrades ($300): The first and (arguably) most valuable benefit of Silver Medallion is the ability to upgrade to first class on most domestic flights plus flights from the US to Canada, the Caribbean and Central America. This was even extended to award tickets in October 2016. Unfortunately, these won’t start clearing until 24 hours before departure, and you’ll fall below all other Delta elites (including their companions), so don’t expect these upgrades to clear with any regularity, especially if you frequently travel during popular times for business travelers. I’ll assume a relatively conservative valuation of $300.
- Unlimited complimentary Comfort+ upgrades on domestic flights, short-haul international flights and Asia Pacific flights ($75): In case you’re not aware, Delta no longer allows elite members to simply select Comfort+ seats on all its flights. Instead, Medallion members now need to request an upgrade on flights within the US and Canada along with the Asia Pacific, Latin America and Caribbean markets. To make this even worse, Silver Medallion members are only eligible to clear into Comfort+ on these flights 24 hours prior to departure. Obviously the true value of this perk depends on how frequently you score a Comfort+ seat and the premium the seats command on your flight, but I’ll peg this perk at $75.
- Unlimited complimentary Comfort+ seat access on flights to other international destinations ($75): On all Delta routes not identified above, Silver Medallions can still access Comfort+ without needing to request an upgrade, though you’ll again be restricted to doing this until 24 hours before departure. I’ll again stay conservative and assume a value of $75.
- Preferred Seats ($50): While you cross your fingers and hope for your upgrade to clear, you can at least select preferred seats for free as a Silver Medallion member. Delta describes these as “choice Main Cabin seats” but are typically just window and aisle seats just behind the Comfort+ cabin. As a result, I’ll peg this perk at just $50.
- Mileage bonus ($110): Silver Medallion members earn 7 miles per dollar spent, 2 more than regular members. With $4,500 MQDs, that equates to 9,000 extra miles, worth $108 based on TPG’s most recent valuations.
- Waived baggage fee ($125): As a Silver Medallion flyer, you’ll enjoy a free checked bag over the standard allowance on most Delta-operated flights, saving $50 per round-trip domestic flight and up to $200 on flights to Europe. This free checked bag within the US can weigh up to 70 pounds, and the benefit extends to eight travel companions in the same reservation. In addition, if you carry a Delta American Express card (like the Gold Delta SkyMiles® Credit Card from American Express), you can actually get a second free bag of up to 70 pounds when traveling within or between the US and Canada. This perk can easily add up if you regularly check a ton of gear, but I’ll peg it at $125.
- Priority check-in and boarding ($50): Silver Medallions are eligible for priority check-in and Zone 1 boarding, but the latter of these is the same offered to Delta American Express cardholders, so neither perk is very valuable.
- Priority phone line ($50): A priority phone line can be a lifesaver during large-scale weather events (or power outages or system issues), but it’s definitely not the most valuable perk.
- Partner perks ($50): Silver Medallion travelers are designated as SkyTeam Elite members when traveling on a SkyTeam airline, which includes priority check-in, boarding and standby plus preferred seating “subject to availability.” You’ll also enjoy additional perks on select partners like AeroMexico, GOL and Virgin Australia (check out this link for full details). These can come in handy if you frequently travel on one ore more of these partner airlines but probably isn’t worth much to the average traveler.
- Crossover Rewards ($5): A non-flying perk for Silver Medallion members is the Crossover Rewards partnership with Starwood Preferred Guest. Unfortunately, this is limited to 1 bonus mile for every dollar spent at SPG properties (and there’s no telling how this program will be affected by the Marriott/Starwood merger). I’m going to peg this at $5, which equates to just over $400 of spending at Starwood properties in a year, though feel free to adjust this if you stay at these hotels more frequently.
- Hertz benefits ($10): In addition to hotel perks with SPG, Silver Medallion members can earn additional bonus miles when renting with Hertz (800 more than a regular member, to be exact). While you may have other car rental companies you use, I’ll assume that you utilize this perk once per year.
Delta Gold Medallion ($2,275)
The second tier in Delta’s program is Gold Medallion status, which normally requires 50,000 MQMs or 60 Medallion-qualifying segments plus $6,000 MQDs. For this analysis, I’ll base my numbers on earning 60,000 MQMs at a cost of 15 cents per mile (so a total spend of $9,000).
- Unlimited complimentary first-class upgrades ($700): Gold Medallion flyers are also eligible for complimentary first-class upgrades on domestic flights and short-haul international flights, and these will start clearing 3 days before departure. Given that you’re prioritized above SIlver Medallions and the additional flying, I’ll bump the value to $700.
- Unlimited complimentary Comfort+ upgrades on domestic flights, short-haul international flights and Asia Pacific flights ($150): You’re also eligible for upgrades to Comfort+ as a Gold Medallion traveler, and these will start clearing 3 days before your flight. I’ll double the value from Silver Medallion due to the additional flying.
- Unlimited complimentary Comfort+ seat access on flights to other international destinations ($150): Gold Medallions can select Comfort+ seats on all other international flights for free, though you must wait until 72 hours before departure to do so. I’ll again double the value from Silver Medallion.
- Preferred Seats ($100): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Mileage bonus ($325): As a Gold Medallion traveler, you’ll earn 8 miles per dollar spent, 3 more than non-status flyers. With $9,000 MQDs, that equates to 27,000 extra miles, worth $324 based on TPG’s most recent valuations.
- Waived baggage fee ($250): Gold Medallion members enjoy a slightly higher baggage allowance than Silver travelers, as they’re allowed to bring two bags weighing up to 70 pounds on flights within the US and Canada.
- Waived same-day confirmed and standby fees ($150): While Silver Medallions and non-status flyers need to pay $75 to standby for or switch to an earlier flight on the day of departure, these fees are waived for Gold Medallions. I’ll assume a utilization of twice per year for this benefit.
- Priority check-in, security, boarding and baggage delivery ($200): You’ll enjoy additional perks at the airport as a Gold Medallion, including priority security and baggage delivery
- Priority phone line ($100): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Partner perks ($125): When you travel on SkyTeam member airlines as a Gold Medallion, you’ll be designated as SkyTeam Elite Plus, granting you a host of added perks like priority security, baggage handling and immigration. As noted above, a handful of partners extend this even further, so be sure to check out this link for more information. I’ll peg these perks at $125, though if you frequently utilize partner airlines, it could be much more valuable.
- Crossover Rewards ($10): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Hertz benefits ($15): Gold Medallion members will enjoy the same opportunity to earn bonus miles with Hertz as Silver travelers, but you’ll also be granted complimentary Five Star Status in the Hertz Gold Plus Rewards program. I’ll stick with my once-per-year assumption from above but add an additional $5 for the status.
Delta Platinum Medallion ($4,025)
The third tier in the SkyMiles program is Platinum Medallion status, which normally requires 75,000 MQMs or 100 Medallion-qualifying segments plus $9,000 MQDs. For this analysis, I’ll base my numbers on earning 90,000 MQMs at a cost of 15 cents per mile (so a total spend of $13,500).
- Unlimited complimentary first-class upgrades ($1,100): Platinum Medallion flyers enjoy the same first-class upgrade perks as Silver and Gold travelers, though you’re prioritized above both of those levels and will start clearing 5 days before departure. As a result, I’ll bump this value to $1,100.
- Unlimited complimentary Comfort+ upgrades on domestic flights, short-haul international flights and Asia Pacific flights ($250): You’ll also be eligible for complimentary upgrades to Comfort+ as a Platinum Medallion flyer, and these will start clearing shortly after ticketing (assuming upgrade inventory is available).
- Unlimited complimentary Comfort+ seat access on flights to other international destinations ($250): For all other international flights, you’re eligible to select Comfort+ seats at the time of booking, a nice bump from Gold Medallion.
- Preferred Seats ($100): Since Platinums will likely clear into Comfort+ or first class, I’ll keep the same valuation I used for Golds.
- Mileage bonus ($650): Platinum Medallion members earn 9 miles per dollar spent, 4 more than non-status flyers. With $13,500 MQDs, that equates to 54,000 extra miles, worth $648 based on TPG’s most recent valuations.
- Waived baggage fee ($325): Your baggage allowance as a Platinum Medallion traveler is slightly higher than what’s offered to Gold Medallions, as you can check up to three bags weighing 70 pounds apiece on flights within the US and Canada (though I doubt many will take full advantage of this perk). Given the additional travel, I’ll bump this benefit to $325.
- Waived same-day confirmed and standby fees ($300): Platinum Medallions enjoy the same fee waivers as Gold Medallions for same-day confirmed and standby, so I’ll assume that you utilize this four times a year given the additional travel.
- Waived award redeposit/reissue fees ($150): One of my favorite benefits from my time as a Platinum Medallion was the ability to change or cancel an award ticket with no fee. This saved me $150 every time I modified a redemption, and I’ll assume that you utilize this once per year.
- Priority check-in, security, boarding and baggage delivery ($300): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Priority phone line ($150): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Choice Benefits ($200): When you qualify for Platinum Medallion, you get to select a Choice Benefit. These include four Regional Upgrade Certificates (RPUs), 20,000 bonus SkyMiles or the ability to gift Silver Medallion to a friend or family member. While you can get some outsized value, especially with the RPUs, I’ll peg this selection at a conservative $200.
- Partner perks ($200): Platinum Medallion members have the same SkyTeam Elite Plus designation as Gold Medallions, but they’ll also enjoy a couple of added perks, including access to Virgin Atlantic lounges outside the United States when traveling on Delta or Virgin Atlantic. As a result, I’ll bump this perk slightly to $200.
- Crossover Rewards ($25): As a Platinum Medallion traveler, you’ll also earn 1 SkyMile for every dollar spent at SPG properties, just like Gold and Silver members. However, you’ll also enjoy added perks like 4pm checkout and space-available upgrades to an enhanced room at check-in. While this can be immensely valuable if you frequent SPG properties, I’ll assume a conservative value of $25.
- Hertz benefits ($25): Platinum Medallion members enjoy 250 more SkyMiles per Hertz rental than Silver and Gold Medallions, and you’ll also receive automatic President’s Circle status in the Gold Plus Rewards program. As a result, I’ll boost the value of this perk to $25.
Delta Diamond Medallion ($8,540)
The final tier in the SkyMiles program is Diamond Medallion status, which normally requires 125,000 MQMs or 140 Medallion-qualifying segments plus $15,000 MQDs. For this analysis, I’ll base my numbers on earning 150,000 MQMs at a cost of 15 cents per mile (so a total spend of $22,500).
- Unlimited complimentary first-class upgrades ($1,500): Diamond Medallions enjoy the highest upgrade priority and will start clearing 5 days in advance (but ahead of Platinum Medallion travelers). As a result, I’ll bump this perk to $1,500.
- Unlimited complimentary Comfort+ upgrades on domestic flights, short-haul international flights and Asia Pacific flights ($300): This priority also extends to Comfort+ seats, as you’re eligible for upgrades shortly after ticketing. I’ll boost this to $300.
- Unlimited complimentary Comfort+ seat access on flights to other international destinations ($300)
- Preferred Seats ($100)
- Mileage bonus ($1,620): Platinum Medallion members earn 11 miles per dollar spent, 6 more than non-status flyers. With $22,500 MQDs, you’ll take home 135,000 extra miles, worth $1,620 based on TPG’s most recent valuations.
- Waived baggage fee ($400): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Waived same-day confirmed and standby fees ($450): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Waived award redeposit/reissue fees ($300): Same benefit, utilized twice per year.
- Complimentary CLEAR membership ($50): Back in 2016, Delta began offering complimentary CLEAR memberships to Diamond Medallion members, a program that continues to expand. However, since it’s still available at a relatively limited number of airports (around 30 as of publish time), I’ll peg this at roughly half of the discounted $99 annual fee offered to all SkyMiles members.
- Priority check-in, security, boarding and baggage delivery ($400): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Priority phone line ($200): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Choice Benefits ($2,600): Things are a bit tricky when it comes to Choice Benefits for Diamond Medallions, especially with the changes announced last year. For starters, reaching Diamond doesn’t mean you skip the Choice Benefit selection as a Platinum. You can still select the perks mentioned above when you reach the qualification threshold for Platinum en route to Diamond, thus giving you $200 of value. Then you’ll be able to select another three Choice Benefits when you qualify for Diamond Medallion. Full details are available at this link, but these benefits include a Delta Sky Club membership, Global Upgrade Certificates, Regional Upgrade Certificates, 25,000 bonus miles or a gift of Gold Medallion status to a friend/family member. It’s virtually impossible to peg a value to this (due to the flexibility inherent in a selection of “choice” benefits), but I’ll assume you pick the Sky Club membership ($400), 4 Global Upgrade Certificates ($400 apiece) and gifted Gold status ($400). Adding in the $200 value from reaching Platinum and you get a total of $2,600
- Partner perks ($250): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Crossover Rewards ($35): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
- Hertz benefits ($35): Same benefit, more frequent utilization.
What if I’m starting from scratch?
As I mentioned at the outset, these numbers are based on the benefits you’d enjoy by spending a full year with the given status. However, if you’re starting from scratch, the calculations become a bit more complicated, since you won’t start to enjoy any benefits until you hit the 25,000-mile mark and earn Silver status. To help modify the analysis for those individuals, I’ve taken the above valuations and converted them to a value per MQM, as follows:
- Delta Silver Medallion: $900 / 30,000 MQMs = 3 cents per MQM
- Delta Gold Medallion: $2,275 / 60,000 MQMs = 3.79 cents per MQM
- Delta Platinum Medallion: $4,025 / 90,000 MQMs = 4.44 cents per MQM
- Delta Diamond Medallion: $8,540 / 120,000 MQMs = 7.12 cents per MQM
I then created an Excel spreadsheet that uses these numbers to calculate how much value you’d get from the different levels of United elite status given a certain amount of flying. All you need to do is change the number in cell A2 to represent the number of MQMs you expect to fly in 2017, and the spreadsheet will update with the corresponding value.
For example, you’ll see that I have pre-loaded 60,000 MQMs. At this rate, you’d get no benefits from the first 25,000 MQMs, then enjoy Silver Medallion benefits for the next 25,000 MQMs (at a rate of 3 cents per MQM), and then enjoy Gold Medallion benefits for the final 10,000 MQMs (at a rate of 3.79 cents per MQM). This means that if you’re starting from scratch and estimate that you’ll earn 60,000 MQMs in 2018, you’d be able to get $1,129.17 worth of perks from the Delta SkyMiles program.
As always, feel free to adjust the numbers above for each tier (loaded into the “Base Data” tab of the spreadsheet) based on your own personal valuation.
Is it worth it?
So given these values, is it worth pursuing elite status (or the next tier of elite status) with Delta? Just like with any analysis we undertake here at TPG, there isn’t an easy answer to this, as it depends entirely on your individual situation. However, here are a few over-arching questions that can help you arrive at a decision:
- How much will you travel in the future? If you earned Delta elite status in 2017, it’s valid through January 31, 2019, and if you qualify in 2018, your status will last until January 31, 2020. It’s critical to think about how much you’ll be traveling in the future. If you push hard to earn Diamond Medallion, for example, the valuable perks outlined above only apply when you actually travel.
- What’s the incremental value of one tier over another? Many of you may wind up within striking distance of the next tier, so be sure to consider whether the benefits are worth pushing for it. There’s no sense in going out of your way for perks that don’t matter to you.
- How well does Delta’s route map match your typical travel patterns? Pursuing elite status with an airline that you can’t feasibly fly on a regular basis is a fool’s errand. Be sure to consider Delta’s service from your home airport(s) and how easy it is to get to your desired destination.
- How sensitive are you to price and convenience? There are many trade-offs in this hobby, and one of the most common is deciding whether to use your preferred airline or hotel chain when it’s not the most convenient or cheapest. Would you book a one-stop Delta flight if Southwest had a cheaper nonstop option? If the answer is no, it may not be worth going out of your way to earn Delta elite status (or any elite status, for that matter).
- Could you enjoy elite-like perks with a credit card? The final consideration involves travel rewards credit cards. Many airline co-branded cards offer perks to cardholders than can mirror what you’d enjoy as an elite member. For example, the Gold Delta SkyMiles Credit Card from American Express includes a free checked bag, priority (Zone 1) boarding and a 25% in-flight discount, while the Delta Reserve® Credit Card from American Express provides complimentary Sky Club access in addition to waived checked bag fees, preferred boarding and the in-flight discount. A couple of these cards even offer bonus miles or even bonus MQMs for reaching certain spending thresholds, helping boost your account or assisting you in qualifying for Delta status without flying. If you can pay a flat annual fee for one of these cards and gain access to perks that matter to you without going out of your way to earn elite status, that may be a good plan.
These questions are also not easy to answer, as there are many different factors that come into play with each of them. Nevertheless, it’s a worthwhile exercise to evaluate your own situation as you determine if Delta elite status is for you!
Earning airline elite status carries an array of perks that can make your entire travel experience more comfortable. However, not all levels with all carriers are created equally, so it’s critical to analyze which elite status program best lines up with your typical travel patterns and what you value most as a traveler. If you’re considering switching your loyalty in 2018, I hope this detailed look at the Delta SkyMiles elite status program has helped your decision!
Feature photo by @pattys0478 via Twenty20
This cash back card has a focus on dining and entertainment where you can earn unlimited 4% cash back in those spending categories. You can also earn 2% cash back at grocery stores and 1% cash back on all other purchases.
- Earn a one-time $500 cash bonus after you spend $3000 on purchases within the first 3 months from account opening
- Earn unlimited 4% cash back on dining and entertainment, 2% at grocery stores and 1% on all other purchases
- No rotating categories or sign-ups needed to earn cash rewards; plus cash back won't expire for the life of the account and there's no limit to how much you can earn
- No foreign transaction fees
- Access to premium experiences in dining, entertainment and more
- $0 intro annual fee for the first year, $95 after that