A tale of two very different American Airlines Boeing 737s

Sep 13, 2019

This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.

Many travelers don’t pay much attention to the aircraft type when selecting a flight. After all, whether you’re flying an Airbus A321 or a Boeing 737, it’s understandable to assume that the onboard experience would be similar between the two on the same airline. At the very least, you might expect that the experience would be similar from one American Airlines 737 to another.

But that’s not the case on American Airlines right now. The airline is working to retrofit the interiors of its domestic workhorses, the Boeing 737 and the Airbus A321. On the 737, AA is adding 12 more economy seats per aircraft, with “slimline” seats have thinner padding and installing bathrooms that are 7 inches smaller.

Once the project — ironically named “Project Oasis” — is complete, those cramped conditions will be found throughout the fleet. In the meantime, there are some drastic differences between American Airlines 737s.

I’ve recently flown both a Legacy American Airlines (LAA) and a Project Oasis Boeing 737. Here’s how the Project Oasis planes are different:

Smaller Lavatories

One of the most drastic differences between the two aircraft was found in the bathroom. Airplane bathrooms aren’t known to be spacious, particularly on domestic aircraft. But AA opted to install much, much smaller bathrooms as part of the Project Oasis makeover.

While the pre-retrofit aircraft have bathrooms that measure 31 inches from wall to wall, the new Project Oasis bathrooms have been shrunk to just 24 inches at their widest spot.

An economy lavatory on an American Airlines Project Oasis 737. (Photo by JT Genter / The Points Guy)

After the inaugural American Airlines 737 MAX flight, I wrote that it was perhaps the worst aspect of the plane. Shortly afterwards, AA flight attendants voiced their complaints about how small the bathrooms were. That didn’t stop AA from installing the same bathrooms on the Boeing 737s as part of Project Oasis.

So, I decided to take a tape measure and see just how the two compare:

Economy lavatory Legacy American Airlines 737 Project Oasis 737
Maximum width 31″ 24″
Minimum width 18″ 18″
Door width 19.5″ 19″
Sink 12″ x 8.5″ 13″ x 5.5

Interestingly, the minimum width of the two bathroom types measured identically. That was surprising considering I saw a passenger of size struggle to get out of the 737 MAX bathroom on the inaugural flight.

However, the main difference is definitely noticeable when it comes to the sink. The un-retrofit aircraft sinks are large enough to comfortably wash your hands.

However, the Oasis bathroom sink measures no more than 5.5 inches long. That can make even the smallest hands feel large. Although I didn’t measure the depth, the Project Oasis sink is noticeably less deep.

(Photo by JT Genter/The Points Guy)

Note that American Airlines didn’t opt to install a smaller bathroom in first class. The only difference in the measurements that I found between the two configurations can be chalked up to rounding.

First Class lavatory Legacy American
Airlines configuration
Project Oasis
Maximum width 31″ 31.5″
Minimum width 19″ 19″
Door width 19″ 19″
Washbin 12″ x 8.5″ 12″ x 8.5″

No Inflight Entertainment Screens

This is likely the first difference that passengers notice between the two aircraft types. While many Legacy American Airlines aircraft have crisp and bright inflight entertainment screens, the Project Oasis aircraft don’t have any screens.

(Photo by JT Genter/The Points Guy)

In case you’re wondering: yes, that means that American Airlines is removing seats that already had relatively new screens and replacing them with newer seats that don’t have a screen. This decision is hitting AA’s financials too. AA had planned to use these screens for at least a few more years, but now it must accelerate writing off their cost.

(Photo by JT Genter/The Points Guy)

On the Project Oasis aircraft, American Airlines encourages passengers to “Bring Your Own Device” and watch the movies and TV shows available for free through the Wi-Fi system. But, unless you travel with a tablet or want to watch on your laptop, you’re going to be stuck watching the entertainment on your phone.

However, the good news is there are nearly identical entertainment options whether you’re watching it on a seatback monitor or on your own device. In September, there are 175 movies on the built-in monitors and 173 movies available through the ViaSat system. Both also offer around 143 hours of TV programming.

Less Pitch and Smaller Seat Padding

You may remember the firestorm that American Airlines set off when it shared plans to install seats with just 29 inches of pitch. While it backed off that plan, both AA’s 737 MAX and Project Oasis aircraft have 30 inches of pitch in standard economy and 33 inches of pitch in extra-legroom Main Cabin Extra. That means there’s less pitch in AA’s extra-legroom seats (33″) than JetBlue has in some standard-legroom seats (34″).

(Photo by JT Genter/The Points Guy)
Back row of the Project Oasis economy cabin. (Photo by JT Genter/The Points Guy)

In first class, there’s supposed to be 37 inches of pitch, although I only measured 36 inches on my Project Oasis flights.

First class on Project Oasis 737-800. (Photo by JT Genter / The Points Guy.)
First class on Project Oasis 737-800. (Photo by JT Genter / The Points Guy.)

Despite this, American Airlines points out that there’s more personal space and more legroom in this new interior than the old interior. And I was surprised to see a 6 foot, 4 inch man sit in AA’s 30-inch pitch seats and not have his knees touch the back of the seat in front of him.

How’s this possible? Part of it is accomplished through the shaping of the seat. But there’s only so much that can be accomplished that way. The rest of that knee room is created by reducing the seat padding. On my Project Oasis flights, I measured just 2 inches of seatback padding in economy and 3 in first class.

That’s a stark difference from the Legacy American Airlines 737 aircraft, where I found more than 3 inches in economy and a whopping 5.5 inches of seat back padding in first class.

First class seats in a Legacy American Airlines 737-800. (Photo by JT Genter / The Points Guy.)

Overhead bin space

One of the advertised benefits of Project Oasis was “larger overhead bins.” While some of American Airlines’ aircraft could really use some more overhead bin space, the legacy 737s weren’t exactly lacking.

American Airlines introduced Project Oasis at the Media and Investor Day in September 2017 with this slide.

In my flights on both versions of AA’s 737, I didn’t notice — or think to measure — the overhead bins. But an AA spokesperson confirmed that the Project Oasis overhead bins are indeed bigger. The not-yet-retrofit 737s have “Boeing Sky Interior pivot bins” while the Project Oasis are retrofit with Boeing’s new “Space Bins.”

Those may sound similar, but there is a difference. Boeing advertises the Space Bins as holding six carry-on bags instead of the four that would fit in the previous Sky Interior pivot pins. That means 50% more bag capacity — at least if everyone puts their bags in the right way.

(Photo by JT Genter/The Points Guy)

What’s Not Different

Wi-Fi: From when the first Project Oasis aircraft entered service in May 2018 until June 2019, one benefit of flying on a Project Oasis aircraft was that you knew you’d get access to high-speed satellite-based Wi-Fi. That’s because AA would install a ViaSat Wi-Fi antenna at the same time as it completed the Project Oasis retrofit. However, there’s no longer a difference. All 304 Boeing 737-800s now have satellite-based Wi-Fi.

Seat Width: The Boeing 737 isn’t known for being spacious, and the Project Oasis retrofit isn’t working any miracles to make it any bigger. That said, the Project Oasis armrests are much smaller — giving you a little more hip space but not really serving much of a purposes as armrests.

How to know if you’re booking a Project Oasis aircraft

After learning about the differences, you probably have a preference about which aircraft type you want to get. However, the two aircraft are nearly identical when booking flights, checking in for flights and viewing the flights in the AA app.

The aircraft type is listed as Boeing 737-800, abbreviated to 738 on the website. For example, here’s a flight on a Legacy American Airlines 737 aircraft — featuring in-flight entertainment screens and comfortable seats:

And here are two Boeing 737 flights with Project Oasis interiors.

Eagle-eyed readers may notice one difference: the Wi-Fi symbol on the Project Oasis aircraft has an indicator showing high-speed Wi-Fi where the LAA aircraft has a Wi-Fi symbol without the needle. As AA has now completed its satellite-based Wi-Fi retrofit and all 737 aircraft, all of the 737s should now have high-speed ViaSat connections. However, the two arrangements are currently showing different Wi-Fi indicators.

However, there’s one reliable way to tell Project Oasis 737 from non-retrofit aircraft: the row numbers in first class. Project Oasis flights have rows 1-4 in first class where LAA aircraft are numbered 3-6. And, as you’ll see below, the same flight can vary between the two arrangements from day to day:

Bottom Line

Flying the two aircraft arrangements in close succession provided a poignant example of the direction American Airlines is going with its domestic fleet. American Airlines could have “harmonized” its Boeing 737 aircraft at 160 seats and provided industry-average pitch, inflight entertainment screens at every seat, humane-sized bathrooms, large overhead bins, comfortable seats and satellite-based Wi-Fi.

Instead, American Airlines is removing seats with inflight entertainment screens and fairly-new bathrooms from its fairly-new Boeing 737 aircraft and installing 12 more economy seats with less pitch, no IFE screens and smaller bathrooms. I’m sure that this decision looks great in the financial spreadsheets that management used to plan this retrofit, but it’s not great for the passenger experience.

2018 TPG Award Winner: Mid-Tier Card of the Year
Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card

WELCOME OFFER: 60,000 Points

TPG'S BONUS VALUATION*: $1,200

CARD HIGHLIGHTS: 2X points on all travel and dining, points transferrable to over a dozen travel partners

*Bonus value is an estimated value calculated by TPG and not the card issuer. View our latest valuations here.

Apply Now
More Things to Know
  • Earn 60,000 bonus points after you spend $4,000 on purchases in the first 3 months from account opening. That's $750 toward travel when you redeem through Chase Ultimate Rewards®
  • 2X points on travel and dining at restaurants worldwide & 1 point per dollar spent on all other purchases.
  • Get 25% more value when you redeem for airfare, hotels, car rentals and cruises through Chase Ultimate Rewards. For example, 60,000 points are worth $750 toward travel
Intro APR on Purchases
N/A
Regular APR
17.74% - 24.74% Variable
Annual Fee
$95
Balance Transfer Fee
Either $5 or 5% of the amount of each transfer, whichever is greater.
Recommended Credit
Excellent/Good

Editorial Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here are the author’s alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, airlines or hotel chain, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.

Disclaimer: The responses below are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser’s responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.