Hotels -- and the ick factor -- in the time of coronavirus

Editor's note: TPG doesn't currently recommend traveling. However, I made this trip because I wanted to be closer to my family and help my sister take care of our parents as the coronavirus pandemic continues, with no end in sight. I'm sharing my story not to encourage similar trips, but to provide information for those who must travel.

Last week, my 14-year-old and I did a 1,700-mile road trip from Towson, Maryland (a suburb north of Baltimore), to our family home in San Antonio, Texas. We decided to stop overnight in Nashville, where I had booked a deluxe room with two queen beds at the Kimpton Aertson in midtown.

Related reading: 10 tips for anyone taking a road trip right now

I'm a germaphobe, so hotels always cause me anxiety. Staying in a hotel during the coronavirus pandemic only heightened that anxiety. I'm going to share some observations from my stay and what one hospitality expert thinks you may come to expect from hotels in a post-coronavirus environment.

Related reading: How to ward off coronavirus in your hotel room

When we arrived at about 5:30 p.m., the front door was locked, so the man at the front desk had to let us in. The hotel restaurant was shut down and the lobby was immaculate but completely empty, with a slight smell of cleaning solution. I've never heard a hotel so quiet, even in the middle of the night.

As I checked in, the front desk person was not wearing a mask, and there were no lines on the floor to promote social distancing. As he checked me in, he noted that the housekeeping staff did regular cleanings in the lobby and elevators. He also suggested using food delivery apps if we wanted a meal.

As we opened the door to our room, I was hit with the same slight smell of cleaning solution -- but I still used my own Clorox cleaning product and paper towels that I had brought along on the trip to do my own once-over. What really struck me was all the surfaces in the room I had to think about potentially being contaminated, making me wonder how each room would be fully cleaned once the coronavirus pandemic subsides.

Scanning the Hotel

Going up

Pressing an elevator button is something guests have done without thinking for decades. But we now have to think about everyone who has touched that button. Did they have gloves on? Were their hands clean? How often do housekeepers come in and clean those buttons? I pressed the button with my elbow.

Daily Newsletter

Reward your inbox with the TPG Daily newsletter

Join over 700,000 readers for breaking news, in-depth guides and exclusive deals from TPG’s experts

Email address

Sign up

By signing up, you will receive newsletters and promotional content and agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Have a drink?

There was an ice bucket with the plastic insert, along with tongs and two wrapped glasses. The ice machine was not on, probably because of a fear of spreading coronavirus. How and how often are the ice bucket and tongs cleaned? Is it safe to have unwrapped drinking glasses? (It's a no for me.)

Below the surfaces

I want to reiterate that this room was immaculately clean. That being said, I was taking a much harder look at the surfaces. I wondered about sitting in the chair or on the chaise. I wondered about what lurked on the surface of that lovely marble table. I looked at light switches, outlets, alarm clocks and phones. It looked clean, but I still used my Clorox solution and paper towels to give everything a swipe.

The bathroom

The hotel bathroom is a germaphobe's nightmare. It's the one place you cannot avoid -- plus it has the most hard surfaces where coronavirus potentially can last the longest. There's the tissue and cotton ball holder, the soap dish, the faucets, the toilet (watch those handles), the floor, the towel rack and the shower, including those showers with seating (like this one) and shelves to hold toiletries. All these are normally cleaned after each guest, but how does that look in a post-coronavirus stay?

Those bottles

This gets its own entry. Hotels began announcing in 2018 that they were moving away from individual soaps/body washes, shampoos and conditioners and replacing them with refillable, pump-top dispensers for environmental reasons. (This particular issue didn't affect me then or now, since I always travel with my own toiletries.)

Related reading: The Critical Points: Give me back individual hotel toiletries

The Kimpton Aertson, a four-star hotel, was still providing the pump dispensers for shampoo, conditioner and body wash. It made me wonder how guests will react to them as they begin to stay in hotels again, and whether hotels will go back to single-use bottles.

Related reading: Marriott and IHG are ditching mini shampoo bottles — and that's a good thing

Don't touch that remote

TV remotes are another issue. A 2018 study by Travelmath found that television remote controls are the second-dirtiest surface in a hotel room. Only the bathroom counter scored higher. The remote dropped to third place in 4-star hotels, with a bathroom counter and desk coming in first and second, respectively. I would Clorox those too -- or skip touching them entirely.

Related reading: How to tell if you're staying in a dirty hotel room

A hotel housekeeping manager weighs in

To put my experience in perspective, I checked in with Roxana Heretz-Hayda had a 30+-year career in the hotel industry, with titles including director of housekeeping and manager of property operations at properties in New York City and around the world. I asked her how hotel rooms are usually cleaned and what she expects in a future post-pandemic world.

Related reading: Here's Marriott's plan to fight coronavirus at its hotels

"In hotels with high standards, the housekeeping staff uses color-coded rags to clean different areas." said Heretz-Hayda. "For example, we used orange rags for bathrooms and blue ones for the guest room surfaces to avoid cross-contamination," she said.

The coronavirus can last between 24 hours and seven days, depending on the surface, according to Healthline (a sister company to The Points Guy, owned by parent company Red Ventures).

"When a hotel is vacant, the viruses on the surfaces will not last from one guest to another, particularly if the hotel is careful to rotate which rooms are rented. But the question is, how will they handle things when occupancy picks up again?" Heretz-Hayda asked. "Hotels will not be able to remain at 30% occupancy to have enough time to clean, disinfect rooms, let them air out and hope the surface germs die. At some point, occupancy will pick up."

Related reading: Hilton teams up with Lysol and Mayo Clinic to promise clean hotels

Cleaning things such as light switches and remote controls are part of standard housekeeping practices, said Heretz-Hayda. "But as a housekeeping manager, could I say with absolute certainty that the cleaning staff cleaned each and every surface? I cannot," she said.

"Higher-end hotels usually have the room attendants clean a lower quota of rooms per shift, between 10 and 14 rooms a day. In value-priced hotels, the room attendants may be required to clean up to 24 rooms per day. That is only 20 minutes of cleaning per room, which includes changed sheets and towels." she continued. "Will housekeepers have time to do the thorough cleaning needed during coronavirus? Not unless hotels decrease room attendant quotas to give the staff the opportunity to thoroughly clean and sanitize. Additionally, hotels will have to remain absolutely vigilant in regards to re-enforcing cleaning procedures and chemical usage."

Related reading: Hyatt becomes next major hotel brand to reveal new sanitation standards

Housekeepers will need wear protective gear all day, plus hotels will need more housemen/porters to clean the public areas, said Heretz-Hayda. "Between every check-out and arrival, each guest room will require a more thorough cleaning, which may result in guests having to wait for their guest rooms upon arrival."

Related reading: Here's how hotels can prove to guests they're safe after coronavirus

Bottom line

Ultimately, the customers will bear the cost of these improved services, said Heretz-Hayda. Like airlines, cruise ships and trains, hotels are going to be forced to balance safe, clean hotel rooms and hope that guests will be not only willing to return, but will also be comfortable paying inevitably higher rates.

Related reading: The best hotel credit cards for 2020