Which low-cost carrier should you fly? Comparing Frontier Airlines and Spirit Airlines

May 13, 2020

This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.

During the COVID-19 crisis, our team has temporarily ceased taking review trips. However, we have resumed the publication of new flight, hotel and lounge reviews, from trips taken before the lockdown. We have also been publishing a selection of our most popular reviews from the past year. We hope this will help you choose once we’re all ready to start booking trips again.

Bear in mind that for the foreseeable future, the on-board and ground experiences will be very different from before the pandemic.  

America’s ultra-low-cost carriers have had a bad reputation for years. Before my first flight with Spirit Airlines several years ago, a friend joked that I’d be flying on a “rubber-band plane.” But that’s not justified by any real numbers when it comes to safety; flying an ultra-low-cost carrier, or ULCC as the industry calls them, is as safe as flying the major airlines.

You will definitely find a different passenger experience, though. And in recent years, these carriers have made huge inroads in the U.S. commercial aviation market by offering passengers extremely low prices and then charging an extra fee for just about everything.

(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)
(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)

Spirit Airlines and Frontier Airlines, respectively the largest and second-largest ULCC in the nation by passengers carried, have expanded their route maps significantly and opened up flying to larger swaths of the public in the process. Now, with global travel demand suppressed by the coronavirus pandemic, it’s likely that we’ll see these two airlines — and their peers in the industry — play a large part in restarting the U.S. commercial aviation industry in a meaningful way. Leisure travelers attracted to the low fares that these carriers can offer may return before those who are traveling for business.

For more TPG news delivered each morning to your inbox, sign up for our daily newsletter.

Before the global shutdown of travel began, I gave the two largest ULCCs in the U.S. a go in the same weekend, on flights between New York City and the Miami area. Both flights were operated by new Airbus A320neos, were about the same length and overall felt very similar, though there were some differences that stuck out.

Related: The do-it-yourself airline: A review of Spirit Airlines on the A320neo from New York to Fort Lauderdale

Related: Flight review: What it’s like to fly Frontier Airlines, from Miami to Newark on the Airbus A320neo

(Photo by JT Genter / The Points Guy)

Now, having reviewed both airlines, I’ll compare the two and try to help you determine which one you should choose when the time is right to fly again.

In This Post

Price

We booked last-minute tickets to south Florida during spring-break season, meaning that I didn’t get the rock-bottom prices that you can often find on both of these carriers. The Spirit flight from New York-LaGuardia (LGA) to Fort Lauderdale (FLL) was cheaper at $258 one-way, which included airfare, seat selection, a checked bag and early boarding, all paid for after booking the ticket. I paid a total of $331 for a one-way ticket on Frontier from Miami (MIA) to Newark (EWR), which included airfare, a checked bag and seat selection.

Both carriers allow you to bundle certain aspects of your flight at the time of booking, which is recommended as it will save you some cash. Trust me, you don’t want to show up at the airport without having prepaid for either your checked or carry-on luggage.

Although the Spirit flight was cheaper, your booking experience will depend on a number of factors — the route, when you book and more. Since your mileage will certainly vary, it’s unfair to declare a winner on this front.

Winner: Draw

At the airport

(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)
(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)

Even though airlines don’t have full control over the airport experience, especially at non-hub airports, this is where I noticed the biggest difference.

Related: Flight review: What it’s like to fly Frontier Airlines, from Miami to Newark on the Airbus A320neo

LaGuardia Airport in New York is one of the most loathed airports in the country, but the parts that Spirit could control were managed well. There was an automated system for checking in and checking bags before passing through security. I was able to find my reservation quickly at the kiosk, print my checked-bag tag and drop it at the automated bag drop and then I was on my way.

At the gate, things were calm and organized — not at all what I was expecting from Spirit. The process started a few minutes behind, but zones were enforced effectively, crucial for a low-cost airline where you can pay quite a bit more to board in an earlier zone.

My expectations were surpassed with Spirit, but they were more or less met with Frontier in Miami, which is to say, things weren’t great.

Nothing was automated, and I was stuck waiting in line for for about 20 minutes before I was able to speak to an agent. Was it the end of the world? Hardly, but I was shocked that there were no kiosks and no opportunities for customers to complete check-in and bag-check steps themselves.

The terminal in Miami — largely out of the airline’s control — was pretty bleak. However, the boarding process began on time and was on par with what you could expect with other U.S. airlines.

Winner: Spirit

Related: Everything you should know before flying Spirit Airlines

On board

(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)
(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)

Both of my flights were operated by the same aircraft: the Airbus A320neo, which is essentially your standard-issue A320 with newer, quieter and more fuel-efficient engines. Things looked and felt basically the same once I got to my seat.

Related: The do-it-yourself airline: A review of Spirit Airlines on the A320neo from New York to Fort Lauderdale

Both airlines have very slim seats with hardly any padding. They’re 17.75 inches wide with 28 inches of pitch and no recline.

Each seat has a laughably small “tray table” that could hardly fit my iPhone. Things got even more interesting when I tried to arrange my snacks and drinks on the tray. I wouldn’t even try to use the tray to work on my laptop.

However, there were slight differences that resonated with me. Spirit, for example, had a movable armrest which allowed me to get a little bit more comfortable in my window seat. However, it did not even have a true seatback pocket, which forced me to keep all my personal belongings in my pockets, which is less than ideal especially when space is at such a premium.

After each flight, I left with the same impression: that I was comfortable enough in my seats for the sub-three-hour flights, but any longer would become a different situation altogether. Although I could slightly increase my comfort by moving the armrest on my Spirit flight, the seemingly minor presence of a real seatback pocket on Frontier made all the difference to me.

Winner: Frontier

Related: Everything you should know before flying Frontier Airlines

Amenities and IFE

(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)
(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)

Two words can describe the amenities and inflight entertainment offered on any low-cost carrier within the U.S.: not much. And on both of these airlines, the experience was identical. There were no amenities to speak of. No Wi-Fi, no seatback power, no entertainment. If you’re flying on an ultra-low-cost-carrier, make sure to download your music, podcasts, TV shows, movies and whatever entertainment you want to bring along beforehand, and make sure your devices are charged, and you’ll likely want to bring a fully charged portable power source with you as well.

Winner: Draw

Food and beverage

(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)
(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)

True to form with ultra-low-cost carriers, all food and beverages — yes, that includes water — have to be purchased with both Frontier and Spirit. Both carriers had a printed menu at each seat with all the choices for food and drink. Prices on each airline were about the same and each offered combo options for those flying with others, or for very hungry people like myself.

I found the quality of the food and drink to be equal on both airlines and the prices reasonable.

Winner: Draw

Service

The service I had on both flights was comparable to that which I’ve experienced on numerous domestic short-haul flights on numerous carriers, though the Spirit crew went above and beyond to help a passenger celebrate a birthday on the flight to Florida, which stuck with me and left a very positive impression.

Winner: Spirit

Overall impression

No matter which ultra-low-cost carrier you choose, your experience is likely going to feel about the same. After flying America’s two most popular ULCCs in the same weekend, I left with no qualms about flying either in the future — especially if I can find those legendary cheap fares as we begin to slowly emerge from travel lockdowns. If I had to travel farther than up and down the East Coast, though, I’d likely pay more to stick to my carrier of choice, Delta, when possible.

(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)
(Photo by Nick Ellis/The Points Guy)

Most of the difference between these two carriers came on the margins — a seatback pocket here and a check-in kiosk there — but overall Spirit delivers a more polished package and, in my opinion, does flying on the cheap just a little bit better than Frontier.

Photos by the author unless where otherwise noted.

Delta SkyMiles® Platinum American Express Card

Earn 50,000 bonus miles and 5,000 Medallion® Qualification Miles (MQMs) after you spend $2,000 in purchases on your new card in your first three months of card membership. Plus, earn up to $100 back in statement credits for eligible purchases at U.S. restaurants with your card within the first 3 months of membership.

With Status Boost™, earn 10,000 Medallion Qualification Miles (MQMs) after you spend $25,000 in purchases on your Card in a calendar year, up to two times per year getting you closer to Medallion Status. Earn 3X Miles on Delta purchases and purchases made directly with hotels, 2X Miles at restaurants and at U.S. supermarkets and earn 1X Mile on all other eligible purchases. Terms Apply.

Apply Now
More Things to Know
  • Earn 50,000 bonus miles and 5,000 Medallion® Qualification Miles (MQMs) after you spend $2,000 in purchases on your new Card in your first 3 months.
  • Plus, earn up to $100 back in statement credits for eligible purchases at US restaurants with your card within the first 3 months of membership.
  • Accelerate your path to Medallion Status, with Status Boost®. Plus, in 2021 you can earn even more bonus Medallion® Qualification Miles (MQMs) to help you reach Medallion Status.
  • Earn 3X Miles on Delta purchases and purchases made directly with hotels.
  • Earn 2X Miles at restaurants worldwide, including takeout and delivery and at U.S. supermarkets.
  • Earn 1X Miles on all other eligible purchases.
  • Receive a Domestic Main Cabin round-trip companion certificate each year upon renewal of your Card. *Payment of the government imposed taxes and fees of no more than $75 for roundtrip domestic flights (for itineraries with up to four flight segments) is required. Baggage charges and other restrictions apply. See terms and conditions for details.
  • Enjoy your first checked bag free on Delta flights.
  • Fee Credit for Global Entry or TSA Pre✓®.
  • Enjoy an exclusive rate of $39 per person per visit to enter the Delta Sky Club® for you and up to two guests when traveling on a Delta flight.
  • No Foreign Transaction Fees.
  • $250 Annual Fee.
  • Terms Apply.
  • See Rates & Fees
Regular APR
15.74%-24.74% Variable
Annual Fee
$250
Balance Transfer Fee
N/A
Recommended Credit
Excellent/Good
Terms and restrictions apply. See rates & fees.

Editorial Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here are the author’s alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, airlines or hotel chain, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.

Disclaimer: The responses below are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser’s responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.