American Airlines’ New Fare Options: Bonus Miles, Perks and More Flexible Flight Changes

by on December 12, 2012 · 36 comments

in American

This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.

This morning, American Airlines launched a new set of fare products aimed to bundle some of the extras flyers pay for a la carte or get with elite status. I talked to Rick Eleison, the American Airlines Managing Director of Digital Marketing about the changes and what they mean for flyers.

Until now, customers have just 2 dimensions for choosing their tickets: price and schedule. American is adding a third axis to the decision-making process aimed at giving their flyers more value without resorting to the nickel and diming of a la carte add-ons.

As Eleison sees it, the age of one-off fees for various perks such as checked luggage and priority boarding was just an adolescent phase in the evolution of fare pricing, and this is a move to “change the conversation by leading the industry back from a line of products to the value of their product line.”

While that may seem like corporate speak for trying to squeeze more revenue out of passengers, I was actually very surprised by the new products being launched and may considering purchasing them, even as an Executive Platinum member.

American will now break down its Main Cabin economy fares in three different tiers for routes within the 48 contiguous United States.

New Domestic 48 Economy Fare Choices

New Domestic 48 Economy Fare Choices

1. Choice Fares: These are basically the discounted economy fares as they are today – the least expensive way to get from point A to point B with no extras added on. You pay fees to make changes and you accrue miles normally.

2. Choice Essential: For an additional fee of $68 roundtrip, these fares will include 1 checked bag, Group 1 priority boarding and no change fees.

3. Choice Plus: These fares cost $20 above Choice Essential (so $88 above Choice/Regular Fares) and have the same three perks as Choice Essential plus a 50% AAdvantage mileage bonus (not Elite Qualifying Miles), waived same-day confirmed flight changes, same day standby and a premium beverage (including alcohol).

I asked for some clarification on a few of the points and here’s what I found out: will start automatically displaying these 4 fares during the booking process as well as discount and full-fare business and first fares. American will also be distributing all these fares through all channels through which you can now buy American tickets. Just note, the airline is not sure about those channels’ abilities to display or present the product, so their availability through sources other than may vary.

Change fees are waived, but if the fare on the new ticket is higher, the customer will still have to pay the difference in fares. If the fare of the new ticket is lower, you will be issued a credit in the form of an airline voucher. If you purchase one of the Choice fares, you can change your ticket as many times as you want without a fee.

Don’t worry, elites will still be the first to board. Customers with these purchased fares will just be entitled to Group 1 of general boarding.

The new fares do not include Priority AAccess for security, so if you don’t have elite status, you’ll still be stuck in line.

With the same-day changes, your routing and departure and destination must stay same. There are a few exceptions – such as the fact that JFK and LGA are coded as co-terminals – but otherwise the airports have the stay the same. The same-day flight change will make it easier to switch flights on the same routes and will have a looser availability threshold to be confirmed on a different flight – basically you will be able to same-day change on flights that are up to 96% full if a seat in your class is available.

No need to pay for checked bags with the new fares.

In addition to the mileage bonus on Choice Plus tickets, American still offer bonus miles through its Miles Multiplier.

If you already get perks through your elite status or credit cards such as the Citi AAdvantage Platinum Select, the add-ons you get by purchasing the higher fares are in addition to the perks you already get. So for instance if your status or card entitles you to a checked bag, purchasing Choice Essential or Choice Plus will get you an additional checked bag. Or if you get a 25% elite mileage bonus from Gold status or 100% from Platinum or Executive Platinum, you will get an additional 50% bonus miles on the base mileage of Choice Plus fares (not on your elite bonus).

The premium beverage that is included with Choice Plus is 1 per flight direct (not segment) and is basically any drink you’d pay for, including alcohol or drinks like Red Bull. Your boarding pass will have an indicator on it (either the print out or your mobile boarding pass) and the flight attendants will have the same information on their manifest since they carry these on electronic tablets now. These beverage credits are intended for a particular itinerary and will be deactivated 24 hours after the flight, so no hoarding allowed.

Seating selection is not affected by these new fares. Since seat inventory is a limited item, it was not possible to include select seating choices in the bundled options.

If you choose to buy the Miles Multiplier your bonus will be just on base miles, not on the bonus miles you would earn by purchasing a Choice Plus fare or on any elite bonuses. Each bonus is calculated individually on the base miles earned. I’m still waiting for verification that the 50% bonus is good on the 500-mile minimum that elites earn when flying short routes.

Eleison said that these new fares are designed for customers who still want the lowest fares, but also want to have a fuller, more transparent understanding of what they are turning down for $68 or $88 by understanding how much those individual benefits would cost a la carte.

Even though I get many of these benefits for free as an Executive Platinum, this fare system appeals to me specifically for the confirmed same-days, which I still have to pay $75 for, and the waived change fees since I change my plans all the time and I would appreciate the extra flexibility and saving that $200 penalty. As Eleison said, people will pay for perks that they know will make their experience better and suits their specific needs.

Flyers like me end up paying for these things already – so in certain circumstances where I might need to take advantage of several of them like first changing my flight and then same-day confirming to a different flight, I’m already ahead on fees. When you throw in the extra 50% bonus  miles, I would really be coming out ahead. I would just need to pay for it all up front, which I’m comfortable doing.

That said, at least American has left the option for budget travelers to get a no frills fare without any bundled benefits that flyers who know their plans and stick to them can take advantage of.

The other good thing is that these fares – including the new ones – will all shop up as a single charge as “airfare” when you pay for them so you can still get the travel category spending bonuses on cards like the American Express Premier Rewards Gold card and the Sapphire Preferred.

On a roundtrip transcontinental itinerary from JFK to LAX – a route I’m often on – I’d earn the 4,950 base miles, my 100% elite bonus for another 5,000 miles, plus a 50% bonus if I paid the $88 for Choice Plus for another 2,475 miles. Just on the surface, that would bring my CPM for those bonus miles to 3.5 cents each, which isn’t great, but factor in the waived change fee and Same Day Confirmed and now we’re talking about value- even if I use those extra benefits once every couple trips.

I’m not saying this is for every traveler and every itinerary, but on those longer flights where you think you might want to alter your plans, the extra flexibility these new fares provide could be well worth the extra cost.

As airlines struggle to turn profits, it is interesting to see American lead the pack with new ways to proactively seek new revenue sources. We see all the time that travelers will pay for a better travel experience – whether it is a $450 annual credit card like the Amex Platinum that provides lounge access and other premium travel perks. I like these new changes because they don’t degrade any current elite benefits and even offer elites a solid (and in my honest opinion, affordable) value proposition, since my plans always change and I’m too cheap to pay for refundable fare classes. But $88 to have waived change fees (same day and to other dates), 50% bonus miles, an extra bag and a cocktail if in coach? Sign me up.

Which of the following fares will you likely purchase next time you buy an American flight?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Disclaimer: The responses below are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Previous post:

Next post:

  • สุภา วงค์เมือง

    Too bad booking international ( usa to se asia) can’t be done online ( yet)

  • thepointsguy

    They are just rolling this out for domestic 48, but I’m sure if it is successful they will consider for international

  • Spencer Wheelwright

    Excellent write-up. Thanks.

  • Pingback: New Pricing Display (December 2012, consolidated) - Page 6 - FlyerTalk Forums()

  • mikehamilton

    So for EXP’s back in coach that get their free drink already, do they now get 2 free drinks with the choice plus option? (although FA’s only seem to charge me for the second drink about half the time). I know they say the benefits add on to the existing one, but the free EXP drink seems to still be a lesser-known benefit.

  • thepointsguy

    Yes, you’d get two drinks

  • Craig

    You state that “[c]hange fees are waived… If you purchase one of the higher fares, you can change your ticket as many times as you want without a fee”

    Do you get the difference in ticket price refunded if you change to a lower priced ticket then?

  • mark

    Good write up. So, now way to buy million mile miles, right? I’d pay a lot fo those miles.

  • Jamison

    I’ve always gotten unlimited food and alcoholic beverages in coach as a EXP- sometimes the FA gives me a few extra bottles to take home LOL

  • Ben Hughes

    The $88 extra fee with the 50% bonus is especially worth it on long routes. Let’s say you value AA miles at $0.02. An itinerary of 8,800 miles is then the break-even point for making the $88 be worth it from a mileage acquisition standpoint alone (you gain 4,400 miles by paying the $88). Some long runs to the pacific easily exceed this.

  • johannamead

    As I don’t travel often enough to earn goodies as a frequent flier, I really like the options offered by Choice Essential – and on some particularly chaotic trips, Choice Plus might actually be worth it. I’ve only had to change flights on the same day a couple of times but, oh boy, did it cost me a chunk of change. Ounce of prevention, and all that…

  • MiamiMike2

    That is exactly what I want to know. I often book tickets in advance and find them for less a few days/weeks later. The $68 is really worth it if you get a credit for changing to a lower priced ticket.

  • db

    I would do choice 2 for change fee on most itinerary and choice 3 for long segments. I am an EXP these are all good options to have, thanks for the great write up.

  • thepointsguy

    Confirmed with AA- if the fare goes down you get a voucher for the difference.. pretty awesome

  • vortix

    Since these fees are built into the fare and not a separate add-on, are we to assume that AmEx Platinum card holders can’t get reimbursed from AmEx for these fees? Or is there perhaps a manual reimbursement process that AmEx has for situations like this?

  • vortix

    That’s GREAT news! How long is the voucher good for? One year from original ticket purchase date? One year from original flight date? …?

  • Pingback: American’s New Bundled Pricing ‘Choices’ for Coach Travel - Frequently Flying()

  • lance

    The system ‘Upgrade’ is riddled with kinks… I have been looking for a good fare to get back down to brazil, and the international search is different as well. They now list the total fare on the outgoing flight instead of just that segment. However, to search for lowest fares, there is no longer an option to order from lowest to highest, and they seem to have no logical ordering. So you have to go from tab to tab to search flights. Then when you select the right one way the return trip is also a hassle. Certain pairings decrease your overall roundtrip price, while most increase based on the flight you select….

    I’m sure this is just a glitch, but you think they would test this a little better before launching ;)

  • Patrick

    If we book on, say, Expedia or something, you mentioned that you weren’t clear on what tier that would get you — probably just the base tier.

    Could you then log into the AA website and upgrade to the other two tiers after the fact? Would the pricing be the same?

  • Beanlee

    Until they match Southwest’s no change fee policy … this still reeks of taking advantage of travelers. Especially since people book their flights online now. American continues to hold people hostage simply to change a flight which is something that can easily be done online … as PROVEN by Southwest.

  • NYBanker

    This sounds a bunch like Delta’s SimpliFares (excluding the fare cap that they offered). That program didn’t last long.

  • John

    hey points guy,

    the inspiration came from there:!

  • Nirav Desai

    This smells of something that Frontier’s been doing for several years. I think it’s a pretty good model.

  • Pingback: New Pricing Structures are Not Fare to the Consumer | Title Goes Here()

  • Charles Clarke

    That’s what I was thinking…

    Frontier has some other good policies. Just need to work on the footprint and the execution.

  • Pingback: » American Airlines' New Fare Options: Bonus Miles, Perks and More …USAkidtoday: Everything you need()

  • Pingback: No More Priority AAccess for Citi AAdvantage Cardholders | The Points Guy()

  • Pingback: American Offering AAdvantage Members Opportunity to Buy-back Elite Status | The Points Guy()

  • Pingback: Maximize Monday: Choosing the Best Site and Credit Card for Purchasing Airfare | The Points Guy()

  • Alan Fowler

    I didn’t see this option when booking a multi-city itinerary. How do I know what fare I got and how do I try to get in on this?

  • Pingback: Why I Love American’s New Choice Fares | The Points Guy()

  • Pingback: The Best Travel Insurance Policy: Miles and Elite Status | The Points Guy()

  • Pingback: New Pricing Structures are Not Fare to the Consumer | Tripzon Blog()

  • Jim

    I like Choice Plus. If the fare drops I’ll get a voucher. I can buy the ticket as far out as I want and watch for a drop. JMO

  • Pingback: Delta Launches Smart Travel Pack: Bundled Benefits For A Fee | The Points Guy()

  • E

    can we upgrade to choice plus after purchase?

Print This Page