TPG reader credit card question: What premium credit card should I use for all spending?

Update: Some offers mentioned below are no longer available. View the current offers here.

It's almost time for spring cleaning. That probably entails purging your closet (unless you're a bit of a clothes hoarder like me), dusting for the first time in weeks (er, months?) and deep-cleaning the kitchen. For many TPGers, it also means taking a hard look at the credit cards we use for everyday spending to decide what's worth keeping and how we should adjust our spending on each card. Reader Dominick S. has a question along these lines:

[pullquote source="DOMINICK S."]If you were to choose just one premium card to put all spending on which would it be?

I am trying to simplify my life and having to remember which card to use is becoming a hassle.

Thanks for the help![/pullquote]

First, let's define "premium card." Most of the time, we are referring to cards with high-end perks and annual fees over $400. For this question, I'm going to extend the definition to include any card with an annual fee of $250-plus because there are a few cards with mid-level annual fees that offer premium perks.

Want more credit card news and advice delivered to your inbox daily? Sign up for the TPG newsletter.

Now, let's look at your premium card options with annual fees ranging from $250-$550:

The information for the Citi Prestige has been collected independently by The Points Guy. The card details on this page have not been reviewed or provided by the card issuer.

As you can see, some premium cards offer better rewards on spending across several categories.

You'll notice that I left out airline credit cards and hotel credit cards. To keep it simple, I'm going to focus on the cards that earn transferable currencies. Cobranded credit cards earn points and miles that are almost always less valuable when it comes to everyday spending. They are great for travelers loyal to a specific travel brand, but I'm focusing on stand-alone credit cards for all spending.

Let's take a deeper dive to figure out which premium card might be the best option for Dominick.

Chase Sapphire Reserve

The Chase Sapphire Reserve starts by offering 50,000 bonus points after you spend $4,000 in the first three months from account opening, worth $1,000 according to TPG valuations. On spending, you'll get 3x on travel and dining purchases worldwide. That may not sound like much, but remember that Chase defines both travel and dining broadly, so you're getting a 6% return on far more than just airfare and hotels.

Let's say you're spending $4,500 on airfare and dining each year, $1,000 on hotels or cruises and $12,000 on non-bonus spending. That's 37,500 Ultimate Rewards points per year, worth about $750.

Similar to the Amex Platinum, you also need to consider the value of the perks you get with the card — Priority Pass lounge access, an easy-to-use $300 travel annual credit and amazing travel protections that can save you real money in the event of travel delays or cancellations. These benefits make a compelling argument for using this card for all of your spending — even if there are technically cards out there that could earn more points. Enrollment required for select benefits..

To put it in context, The Points Guy himself, Brian Kelly, says that the one premium card he'd choose for all spending is the Chase Sapphire Reserve.

Related: Chase Sapphire Reserve review

The Platinum Card® from American Express

Although The Platinum Card from American Express is definitely one of the top travel cards (and the winner of TPG's battle of the premium cards), it falls short in the area of earning rewards on everyday spending. You're getting a nice welcome bonus of 80,000 points after you spend $6,000 in the first six months of card membership. The welcome offer is worth $1,600 according to TPG valuations — to start with.

The 5x bonus on airfare and hotels booked directly or through Amex Travel makes the earning potential on this card pretty limited beyond that.

There is a scenario where having only the Amex Platinum card still makes sense despite the limited bonus categories: The value you get out of the card's perks and benefits outweighs the value of the rewards you'd get by charging your spending to another card.

Here's a rundown of TPG's estimated value of a few of the Amex Platinum's benefits:

• Annual airline fee credit: Up to $200.
• Annual Uber credit: Up to $200.
• Annual Saks credit: Up to $100.
• Priority Pass Select membership: $429 (based on the unlimited access option available for purchase).
• Delta Sky Club access: $545 (based on the cost of the purchasable membership).
• Hilton Honors Gold elite status: $1,255.
• Marriott Bonvoy Gold elite status: $840.
• Total: $3,569.

Enrollment required for select benefits.

That's more than $3,500 in annual value, not even including the current welcome bonus or perks that are harder to quantify, such as Centurion Lounge access, access to Amex Fine Hotels & Resorts and Uber VIP status. If you don't think you'd get that much in value from other credit cards with broader spending categories, this is still a great option.

Related: Amex Platinum review

Citi Prestige® Card

The Citi Prestige offers a nice return across an array of spending categories and, with an annual fee of $495 per year, it's one of the only "ultra premium" credit cards that hasn't increased its fee to $550-plus.

If the majority of your spending is on travel and restaurants, you can rack up a ton of ThankYou points with this card. Those are the only spending categories you have at your disposal, but that can potentially stack up over the course of a year.

According to U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics data, the average American expects to spend approximately $300 on dining per month. Additionally, Bankrate's 2019 summer vacation survey (the last survey done) claimed the average American expected to spend almost $2,000 on vacation.

Going off that information, let's say you spend approximately $1,000 on airfare per year, an additional $1,000 on hotels and/or cruises and $3,500 on dining. Assuming you're spending $1,000 monthly on non-bonus spending, that would total $12,000 per year on non-bonus spending.

At the end of the year, you'd earn 37,500 ThankYou points, worth about $637 according to TPG valuations.

Keep in mind that the Citi Prestige is one of the cards affected by devaluations in 2019, which lessened its appeal to many frequent travelers.

Related: Citi Prestige Review

American Express® Gold Card

Last, but not least, is the American Express Gold Card. This card is sometimes overlooked because it doesn't quite fit in with the high-end cards with $400 annual fees or the mid-tier cards that hover at around $95.

But there is a lot to love about it. For an annual fee of $250 (see rates and fees), you're getting a great 8% return on spending with 4x points at U.S. supermarkets (on up to $25,000 per year, then 1x) and 4x at restaurants. Plus there's a nice 6% return on airfare (at three points per dollar spent) booked directly with the airline or Amex Travel.

I use my Amex Gold card for a solid portion of my own monthly spending. The U.S. Bureau of Labor and Statistics reports that the average American spends approximately $375 on groceries each month. Let's say you're spending $4,500 per year at U.S. supermarkets, $3,500 on dining, $1,000 on airfare and $9,000 on non-bonus spending. That means 44,000 Membership Rewards points over the course of a year, which is worth $880 according to TPG valuations.

Plus you still get to take advantage of Amex Offers (which can help you earn rewards and save money on some non-bonus expenses) and earn valuable Membership Rewards without paying a super high annual fee.

The card even comes with a few premium benefits, such as up to $120 per calendar year in dining credits (which I easily use on my own card). It's actually the one card that I couldn't live without and worth strong consideration if you are downsizing your wallet. Enrollment required for select benefits.

Related: American Express Gold Card review

Bottom line

Asking credit card enthusiasts which premium card they would put all of their spending on sometimes feels like asking us to pick a favorite child. It really comes down to your spending habits and what you're looking for.

Personally, I'll sacrifice some of the more luxurious perks in order to maximize as much of my spending as possible for earning rewards. That's why I love my Amex Gold card. However, some people are willing to give up higher earning rates for benefits like complimentary elite status or lounge access.

This should be a good start in helping Dominick narrow down options and figure out which premium card is the best choice for him.

For rates and fees of the Amex Platinum Card, please click here.
For rates and fees of the Amex Gold Card, please click here.