Three US Airways Policies I Want American Airlines To Implement

by on May 6, 2014 · 8 comments

in American, US Airways

This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.

Most American Airlines flyers that I talk to are nervous that the merger with US Airways will bring about almost all negative changes. I have to say that they aren’t off to a great start. With US Airways management now mostly at the helm, we’ve seen a string of negative changes, including the nixing of bereavement fares, increase in Choice fares and overnight devaluations in AAdvantage. However, I’m trying my hardest to be an optimist and I’m hoping we see some positive changes down the line and I hope they make some positive changes, some of which US Airways already offers to their consumers. So if I had my pick, here are my top three improvements to the new American based on existing US Airways policies.

1) Improve the Same Day Change Policy- no matter if you’re an Executive Platinum or lowly non-elite member, you need to pay $75 to switch to another flight on the same calendar day as long as the origin and destination remain the same and their is availability (you need to call, AA does not release same day change availability online).  Changes are only good on US/Caribbean flights and only for coach reservations. Booked in first or business? You’re out of luck and need to pay a change fee and re-fare, which is never pretty.

US Airways gives free "MoveUp" flight changes to elites

US Airways gives free “MoveUp” flight changes to elites

In comparison, US Airways has the MoveUp program that has a smaller window of flexibility, but is available on all US flights both domestic and international.  It costs $75 for flights within the United States, Latin America, the Caribbean and Canada and $150 to move up on flights to/from Europe, Israel and/or South America. You can only change to flights within 6 hours of your original scheduled departure, on the same day with the same number of stop and all flights have open seats (if you have connecting flights)

But get this: US Airways waives the MoveUp fee for Dividend Miles Preferred and AAdvantage elite status members.

Dream scenario: I really hope American takes the best aspects of both programs, allowing the greater time window of AA’s flight changes with the flexibility to change both domestic and international flights and waiving the fee for all elite members.

2) Award Routing: After American’s stealthy AAdvantage changes recently, you can no longer build in stopovers on international awards of more than 24 hours and they got rid of their valuable Explorer Awards. AA also has strict routing rules where your award needs to have a published fare between your origin and destination, which means that some seemingly valid itineraries are not allowed.
US Airways allows round-the-world routing on many international awards

US Airways allows round-the-world routing on many international awards

US Airways on the other hand allows some of the most incredible, flexible routings- including crossing both oceans when going to Europe or Asia- meaning you can book “round the world” trips as normal awards- or 1oo,000 miles to go to Europe, coming home with  stop in North Asia and crossing both oceans. It actually used to be cheaper to go to North Asia with a stop in Europe (90,000 miles before the stealth changes) than it was to just go roundtrip to Europe (100,000 miles), but now they changed North Asia business class roundtrip awards to be 110,000 miles.

Dream scenario: The new AAdvantage rules allow one-way awards, but also US Airway’s current routing and stopover/open jaw rules and they also take away US Airways’ current draconian rule of no changes after your travel on your first leg of an award.
3) Elite Qualification: American has a weird system of either qualifying for elite status via points or miles. Under the points system, premium fares get 1.5 points, middle of the road fares 1 point and cheap economy fares .5 point per mile flown. So if you fly a lot of premium fares, it makes it easier to get status, which makes sense to reward your customers shelling out more. However, if you fly a mixture of premium and cheap coach, you get penalized for the cheap economy fares and may end up behind where you are in elite qualifying miles. EQMs are simply 1 EQM per mile flown, regardless of fare class. So with most other frequent flyer programs, if you fly a mix of cheap coach (100% base miles) and premium (150-200%) then you combine both to cumulatively achieve a higher status. With AA it is one or the other and if you qualify on points then the 10k EQMs for spending $40,000 in a calendar year from the Citi Executive AAdvantage card are worthless.
US Airways Elite Qualifying Chart

US Airways Elite Qualifying Chart

Dream scenario: American uses one system of Elite Qualifying Miles for elite status and uses US’ chart of 100% for base fares and 150% for first/business (and add full-fare economy fares at 150% as well). In addition, they keep the BarclayCard method of elite miles where you earn 10,000 Elite Qualifying Miles after only $25,000 spend on the Dividend Miles World Mastercard vs. the $40,000 required on the Citi Executive AAdvantage.

This is by no means a final list, but just some of the key areas I’d like to see changes in the AAdvantage program. What would you like to see in the new combined program?

Disclaimer: The responses below are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Previous post:

Next post:

  • LAKnight

    Speaking of US Airways Dividend MasterCard, let’s keep our fingers crossed the annual companion tickets will still be available when 2 mileage programs merge…

  • thepointsguy


  • Keith Griffin

    That’s the only reason I use that card. Well, the $25,000 thing is good, too.

  • PatMcPSU

    How about the best part about US Air? Unlimited first class upgrades for all tiers!

    I might have a rage blackout if I ever see empty seats on the front of the plane for a domestic flight. Also, the 500-mile upgrades sound like a huge hassle.

  • Salamacuse

    It all sounds nice but AA redemptions are already tougher to come by. Try finding JFK-LAX saver business from here until the calender runs out. It’s not there. AA has become UA and it stinks. Earn and burn.

  • Steve

    I have a feeling this is because they recently launched the new lie-flats JFK-LAX in business which is a steal at 30k points. That in addition to all of the Citi Executive 100k points being given out in the last 3 months.

  • Steve

    “Booked in first or business? You’re out of luck and need to pay a change fee and re-fare, which is never pretty.”

    In other words, the phone agent lied to me when she said I should myself and fiance on two different flights returning home since we can both move to one with open seats if available. Sounds like she wasn’t wrong but failed to mention what was involved. Worth calling to see if they can do anything?

  • KK

    companion tickets are being discontinued after 2014.

Print This Page