Airline Consolidation Means More Flight Delays and Cancellations

by on April 26, 2014 · 6 comments

in Airline Industry

This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.

I read an interesting article on Bloomberg yesterday that noted a study ordered by Congress found that decreased competition in the airline industry thanks to major airline mergers like those of Continental/United and Delta/Northwest have meant a rise in flight delays and cancellations since 2005. The study looked at 2,500 routes and statistics from 2005-2012.

More mergers mean more flight delays.

More mergers mean more flight delays.

Mitchel Behm, an Assistant Inspector General of the Department of Transportation noted in the report that, “When competition decreased, both the average length of flight delays and percentage of total flights that were late increased.” Backing that claim up: in markets where the airline presence went from three major carriers down to 2, flight delays were lengthened by over 25%, and cancellations went up by 7%. In 2013, the DOT noted that 1.5% (or 96,000) flights were canceled and 22% (or 1.27 million) flights were delayed 15 minutes or more.

While the main message seems pretty clear, I actually think the statistics are slightly more mixed than they seem at first. That’s because the study ended just as the merger between United and Continental was finally cemented and the airline began operating as a single entity so hopefully since then they’ve ironed out some of their issues. That said, we’re bound to see a lot more headaches as the US Airways/American Airlines merger progresses, so those numbers could shoot right back up again.

All in all, I don’t think the results are terribly surprising given that where there is less competition there is less incentive to perform well. According to this CNN article from last year, mergers also result in more delays/cancellations, but also less dire but still annoying downsides like more lost luggage and passenger complaints. The one bright spot? Mergers haven’t meant skyrocketing airfares so far. The year-over-year increase in average airfares is just about 2% since 2004 despite several major mergers.

The American US Airways news is only the latest in a string of high-profile airline mergers.

Will the US/AA merger mean even more headaches?

Still, it seems like flyers have had and are in for more delays and cancellations in the coming days and years. It seems like every other flight I’m on has an issue or two and I actually count myself lucky when we take off and land on time as it’s becoming more of a rarity. No wonder people hate airlines so much (and why United is at the bottom of the list!).

What do you think? Have these mergers led to more delays and cancellations in your own travel? Share your experiences below.

Disclaimer: The responses below are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Previous post:

Next post:

  • Steve

    I’d imagine it has more to do with the onerous penalties for tarmac delays, which came into force in 2010… Airlines don’t like cancelling flights.

  • Ed

    Post Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc

  • DG153

    Hmm.. I’ve never had any problems with United and I fly them the most since I live near their hub in Newark. Southwest on the other hand…..

  • Rosemary Grado West

    Are you kidding??? Prices haven’t skyrocketed since the mergers? My Continental roundtrip from SAN-BWI in 2012 was $198. Then it went to $298, $398, and, with the merger w/United, my June flight this year is $712, scheduling my same favorite flights for my granddaughter’s birthday. And, as Silver Preferred (lowest preferred status level), I NEVER get upgraded to 1st Class because of the merger with United and the large amount of people in this classification. I frequently got upgraded in the past! I seriously believe that there is little benefit in maintaining Silver Status and that many other flyers will “shop around” for lower fares rather than remain loyal to one airline. Where’s the JOY?

  • Laura616

    You need to have premier 1K status these days to get upgraded. My husband does well with upgrades because of his status but the number of seats in first class has been reduced considerably so it doesn’t always happen.

  • AlaskaGeo

    Well, on Alaska I have flow 500,000 miles in the last 6 years and have only had 2 cancellations. On time or early is the rule and I have never missed a connection. I can only imagine what it is like to travel on a mega carrier, where you “count yourself lucky” when the plane takes off and lands on time.

Print This Page