Should I Charge My Marriott Stay On My Marriott Visa Or Citi AAdvantage Card?

by on June 23, 2013 · 6 comments

in American, Chase, Citi, Marriott, Sunday Reader Questions, Video Blog Post

This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.

Update: The current offer for the Marriott Rewards Premier Visa is 50,000 points with $1,000 spend in the first 3 months.

TPG Twitter follower Adam has a question about American Airlines’ new partnership with Marriott where you can now earn AAdvantage miles on Marriott stays:

“@thepointsguy so is it better to charge a Marriott stay with the Marriott Premier Rewards Visa or the Citi Platinum Select AAdvantage card, now that the partnership is formed?”

Earlier this week American Airlines announced that you can now earn AA miles staying at Marriott. This wasn’t a huge piece of news because you could already earn miles with Marriott’s other airline partners, which also include Air Canada, Air France/KLM, Alaska, British Airways, Delta, Emirates, Hawaiian, JetBlue, Lufthansa, Singapore, Southwest, United, US Airways and Virgin America among many others.

However, it is good news for people who want to stay at Marriott and boost their AAdvantage accounts since you can now choose to earn up to 2 AAdvantage miles per $1 you spend at Marriott instead of Marriott points.

The short answer to Adam’s question is: any of Citi’s AAdvantage cards will only earn you one mile per dollar spent, bringing your total per-dollar earning on Marriott spend to 3 miles if you have elected to earn American miles instead of Marriott points. On the other hand, the Marriott Premier Visa will give you 5 Marriott points per dollar you spend at Marriott on top of the 10 points per $1 you already earn (at most of their brands) as a general Marriott Rewards member, bringing your total earning to 15 points per dollar.

Marriott Airlines

Where this starts to come into play is that Marriott also allows you to convert points to airline miles at the following ratios (although transfers can take 6-8 weeks to go through):

10,000 points =  2,000 miles
20,000 points =  5,000 miles
30,000 points =  10,000 miles
70,000 points =   25,000 miles
140,000 points = 50,000 miles

So by comparison, at the low  levels when you transfer 10,000 Marriott points to American Airlines you are getting 2,000 AAdvantage miles for every 10,000 points transferred. That’s 5 points to 1 mile – the same as the difference in earning rates when you use the co-branded credit cards to pay for your Marriott stays, as I mentioned above. So basically, whether you’re using your

However, as you transfer more points, the ratios get more lucrative – ranging up to 2.8 Marriott points to 1 airline mile. So if this is a long-term strategy of yours I recommend using the Marriott Rewards Premier Card for your Marriott stays because you’ll get more than one AA mile per 5 Marriott points transferred.

So to take a quick example, if we’re just talking about using these credit cards on Marriott stays, in order to end up with 50,000 American miles, you’d need to spend $16,667 on your Citi American AAdvantage credit card or $9,334 on your Marriott Premier Visa to end up with the 140,000 points you’d need to convert to 50,000 miles.

However, if you really want to rake in the AA miles, none of this may  make a whole lot of sense. Instead, if you have the Starwood Preferred Guest American Express and use it to pay for Marriott stays will actually get on average 1.25 AA miles per dollar because Starwood Preferred guest points transfer to American Airlines and every 20,000 points you transfer ends up as 25,000 American Airlines miles. Essentially you are getting a 1.25 ratio on AA miles for all purchases.

I would probably go with the Marriott Rewards Premier Visa in this situation, but if you want to get the SPG Amex, hopefully later this summer they will increase the bonus to 30,000 Starpoints like they have been doing for about a month every summer for the past couple of years and get in on it then if it comes around.  If not, I’d suggest using your Marriott Rewards Premier Visa.

Disclaimer: The responses below are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Previous post:

Next post:

  • Scott

    The Ritz Carlton Credit Card gets you 5 pts per dollar spend at Marriotts now as well.

  • UnitedWeFall

    Actually, this leans even more in the Marriott Visa’s favor. If you have the Marriott Visa, you have automatic Silver Elite status and receive a 20% points bonus with each stay. 15 points x 1.20 = 18 Marriott rewards points for every dollar charged on Marriott-related expenses with the card.

  • UnitedWeFall

    Unless the 20% bonus applies to partner miles, too (wiping out the added bonus). Not sure, though. The Marriott Visa is the next card on my to-get list. Waiting for a limited-time sign up offer.

  • CVG_Traveler

    If Marriott Elite status is a concern, then I think it is best to use the Marriott Visa because you get 1 elite night for every $3K in spend. Considering that Marriott has higher night thresholds for the Gold and Platinum levels, this can really help status achievement if you spend a lot of your nights at Marriott properties.

  • Scott

    Or just get the Ritz Carlton card and have immediate Gold status and maintain it with just 10k in annual spend.

  • Christian

    SPG advice is dodgy — if you spend $20k@Marriott on SPG Amex, you get 25K AA, if you spend $20k@Marriott on Marriott Visa you get 35K AA… Plus with the Marriott Visa, you only need to spend $4665@Marriott to get the most lucrative transfer rate ($4665 = 70K).

Print This Page